Pastor Jack Hibbs Says "The Republic Is Over," Wants to Beat Up Christians Who Didn't Vote

FEATUREDNEWS

11/16/20262 min read

Why it matters: One of the most-watched pastors on the Christian right told his church the midterms ended America, and that the Bible gives him permission to rough up the Christians who stayed home.

The big picture: In a post-election message at Calvary Chapel Chino Hills, Hibbs blamed the blue wave on Christian no-shows and on Muslim candidates winning office. He said he'd like to "be like Nehemiah," find every Christian who didn't vote, "grab them by the beard," throw them into the street and beat them up. "It's biblical. Nehemiah did it." He posted the clip on X.

By the numbers:

  • 17%: white evangelicals' share of the 2026 electorate, down from 24% in the 2022 midterms and 23% in 2024 (exit polls)

  • About 6 million: estimated drop in white evangelical voters from the 2022 midterms (Washington Stand analysis of exit-poll data)

  • 66%: turnout in 343 "evangelical hub" counties, measured against their 2024 vote (American Communities Project)


What they're saying: "The republic ended on Tuesday." Hibbs, to his congregation. "Those of you who didn't vote, you voted."

The oath question: Hibbs told his church that Muslim officials "cannot swear allegiance to the Constitution" because "it is forbidden in Islam. They must swear allegiance to Sharia law." His critics point out that Muslim officials take the same oath of office as everyone else, and they do. The real question is whether a good Muslim is bound by that oath, and Islam's own sources leave a door open that the Bible keeps shut.

  • The Quran lets believers befriend unbelievers outwardly "as a precaution" (3:28).

  • Al-Tabari, Islam's most revered commentator, explains it: be friendly with your tongue while your heart is opposed.

  • Al-Ghazali, Islam's most celebrated theologian, taught that lying is obligatory when it's the only way to reach an obligatory goal.

The Bible permits none.

The bottom line: Hibbs is right that it's a sin for a Christian not to vote. But the republic isn't over. To win back control of Congress and the White House, Christians will have to make a public choice about whether they will serve God or not.

THE FAITH CHECK: "If anyone, then, knows the good they ought to do and doesn't do it, it is sin for them" (James 4:17). Notice the word "knows." When Nehemiah pulled out men's hair (Neh. 13:25), it wasn't for something they didn't understand. Years earlier, with enemies circling the half-built wall, he had already told the people what was expected of them: don't be afraid, remember the Lord, and fight for your families (Neh. 4:14). They knew what they should have done. That same call is on Christians today: fight for your families.

You should probably know: If the republic ended on Tuesday, who exactly is he asking to show up in 2028?

Original reporting by ChurchLeaders.

Faith Check News

Curating daily news stories for Christian readers.

CONNECT OTHERS

© 2026. All rights reserved.