Democrats Claim Mandate to Address Affordability While Promising Unaffordable Programs

FEATUREDNEWS

11/19/20264 min read

They promised to lower your costs. The first big items on their health care list would hand taxpayers the largest new bill in American history.

Why it matters: Voters picked Democrats to make life cheaper. The party's shattered Obamacare promises and its single-payer cost projections point the other way.

The big picture: Jeffries says Democrats will focus on lowering everyday costs. But near the top of their to-do list: reversing the 2025 Medicaid cuts, moving the Dream and Promise Act "early in the next Congress," and a House plan that includes a Medicare for All vote within the first year. Reversing the cuts would put refugees, asylees and parolees back on Medicaid, and the Dream and Promise Act puts millions on a path to green cards and federal benefits.

By the numbers:

• $32.6 trillion: new federal spending over 10 years for Sanders' plan, and that's the low-end estimate (Mercatus). The left-leaning Urban Institute lands closer to $40 trillion.

• 40%: how far Medicare rates run below private insurance. The low estimate only works if every doctor and hospital takes that cut.

• 80%+: share of hospitals that would lose money treating their patients at those rates.

• 28%: share of Medicare Part B that seniors cover through premiums today. Medicare for All zeroes out premiums, deductibles and copays, so taxpayers pick up the tab.

• $1.8 trillion: what one 10-year single-payer estimate adds for covering just 11 million illegal immigrants (American Action Forum). A Yale/MIT model put the real number as high as 29.5 million, and that was before the Biden-era surge brought the biggest two-year jump on record.

Moderation? Look left:

• Jeffries' pitch was stopping "MAGA extremists." His words: "either MAGA extremists are going to break the country, or we're going to break them."

• His fix for extremism is the Democratic Socialists' "top national priority," Medicare for All. NYC's DSA chapter just voted 291–123 to draft AOC for president, and she already co-leads House Democrats' health care working group.

What they're saying:

• Jeffries: "We're going to move the Dream and Promise Act in the next Congress, early in the next Congress."

• Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed told Current Affairs in September that private coverage would be "entirely redundant." In October, asked at a debate whether families could keep their private health care: "Yes, absolutely." The bill bans selling coverage that duplicates the program.

The other side: Supporters say single-payer ends premiums and cuts insurance paperwork. But the "savings" only appear if hospitals take a roughly 40% pay cut. If Congress backs off the cut, the analyst behind the $32.6 trillion figure says costs run "substantially higher."

The elephant in the waiting room: Obamacare.

• Obama promised to cut a typical family's premium "by up to $2,500 a year." Instead, premiums for people buying their own coverage more than doubled in four years, up 105% from 2013 to 2017.

• Benchmark premiums, before subsidies, jumped 26% in 2026 and another 13% for 2027.

• Frosting on a cow pie. That's the subsidy. It gets paid straight to the insurance company, the sticker price keeps climbing, and Washington pays the insurer to hide it.

• California already ran the test. Opening Medi-Cal to adults regardless of immigration status cost an extra $8.5 billion a year, the state borrowed $3.4 billion to cover it, and Democrats froze new enrollment. Medicare for All would run the same experiment nationwide.

The bottom line: Hiding the price tag isn't lowering the price. Nobody can tell you what single-payer really costs, because the bill never says how many people it covers. It covers every "resident," never excludes people here illegally, and lets the HHS Secretary add anyone else "to ensure that every person" gets care. Even a group that backs the bill says it "appears to allow HHS to include both documented and undocumented immigrants." Omission is permission. Every one of those trillions comes out of the same paychecks that cover rent and groceries.

THE FAITH CHECK: Jesus asked a question every Congress should have to answer before it votes: "Suppose one of you wants to build a tower. Won't you first sit down and estimate the cost to see if you have enough money to complete it?" (Luke 14:28, NIV). I'm not saying Jesus would or would not endorse single-payer. I'm saying he would challenge us to count the cost and not be seduced by the promise. Do the math on Obamacare and you find a half-built tower the neighbors are still laughing at. Do it on single-payer and you realize it's Humpty Dumpty 2.0.

You should probably know: Moderates don't put a $32 trillion plan on their first-year to-do list. Democrats ran on affordability, and the wing drafting AOC for president is setting the agenda.

Original reporting by Scripps News.

Read the bill yourself:

• Medicare for All Act, S. 1506 (Sanders), full text. Sec. 102 covers every "resident" and lets the HHS Secretary define who counts: https://www.congress.gov/119/bills/s1506/BILLS-119s1506is.htm

• Medicare for All Act, H.R. 3069 (Jayapal), full text. Sec. 102 lets the Secretary add "other individuals": https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr3069ih/html/BILLS-119hr3069ih.htm

• Jayapal's section-by-section summary, the ban on selling duplicate coverage: https://jayapal.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Medicare-for-All-Act-of-2019-Section-by-Section-Summary.pdf

• Guttmacher Institute analysis. A supporter says the bill "appears to allow HHS to include both documented and undocumented immigrants": https://guttmacher.org/node/30471

• Mercatus Center (Blahous): the $32.6 trillion estimate and the 40% rate gap: https://www.mercatus.org/publications/healthcare/understanding-cbo%E2%80%99s-medicare-all-cost-estimates-0

• Blahous: 80%+ of hospitals would lose money at Medicare rates: https://manhattan.institute/article/how-much-would-medicare-for-all-cut-doctor-and-hospital-reimbursements

Faith Check News

Curating daily news stories for Christian readers.

CONNECT OTHERS

© 2026. All rights reserved.