25 years after 9/11: Homeland Security cost trillions — and can't tell us where it went
We traded a little freedom for a little safety. Now the giant can't account for the money, and the cameras are pointed at us.
NEWSFEATURED
9/8/20263 min read
25 years after 9/11: Homeland Security cost trillions — and can't tell us where it went
We traded a little freedom for a little safety. Now the giant can't account for the money, and the cameras are pointed at us.
Twenty-five years ago this week, a nation in shock made a deal: hand over some freedom, get safety in return. In 2003 we folded 22 agencies into one department, the Department of Homeland Security, and told it to keep us safe at any cost.
It took the "any cost" part seriously. Like a freshman with his first no-limit credit card.
Why it matters: The third-largest department in the federal government has spent 25 years unable to fully explain where its money goes, and its own auditors keep saying so out loud.
By the numbers (per The Center Square, citing DHS, the GAO, and the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget):
DHS opened in 2003 on about $31 billion. The 2027 request is $118 billion.
Roughly $1.6 trillion has been appropriated since 2003. In 2025, auditors handed the department an "adverse" opinion on its own financial controls, and the GAO has kept DHS on its "high-risk" list for years.
The software built to track that spending blew its own budget, climbing from a pitched $79 million to more than $124 million. The money-tracker needed a money-tracker.
"DHS has received a steadily increasing supply of taxpayer resources, yet that funding has failed to deliver," said David Ditch of the Cato Institute.
The big picture: The mission drifted a long time ago. Amy Pate, a researcher at the University of Maryland, says the department is "largely not a terrorism-prevention agency" anymore. Benjamin Franklin flagged the risk 250 years early: a people who trade essential liberty for a little safety tend to end up with neither.
The other side: DHS points to "more than two decades of inflation," modernization costs, and "an increasingly complex threat environment." Bruce Hoffman of the Council on Foreign Relations notes the threat list really has multiplied, from one al-Qaeda to ISIS, its franchises, and domestic terrorism "from both the far left and the far right." The budget multiplied faster.
The surveillance people can actually see: Flock Safety's license-plate cameras aren't a DHS program. They're local. But they're the version of surveillance Americans can see from the sidewalk, and they're striking back at it. This year 149 cities and counties have canceled, rejected, or deactivated the cameras, and Tempe, Arizona shut its off for good on August 28. The objection is the Fourth Amendment, unreasonable searches, and the question of who gets to watch.
The instinct to push back is alive. It's just aimed at what people can see. A camera on a pole is easy to spot and easy to vote out. A $1.6 trillion department is neither. Most Americans will never see that bill, which is exactly how the giant they can't see keeps growing while they take down the one they can.
FAITH CHECK
There's a reason the Bible keeps warning us not to put our trust in people for our security. Scripture saw this exact trade coming, and it didn't flinch.
In 1 Samuel 8, Israel is scared and wants what the other nations have: one big power to keep them safe. God's answer is exact. First comes the diagnosis: "they have rejected me from being king over them" (1 Samuel 8:7). Then the warning about what a centralized king actually does, hammered again and again: he will take. Your sons. Your daughters. Your fields. A tenth of everything. "And you shall be his servants" (1 Samuel 8:11–18).
Catch the pattern. It runs all the way back to Babel, where people centralize to "make a name for ourselves" and God's response is to scatter them (Genesis 11:4–8). He decentralized power on purpose. The One who knows the human heart best trusts it least with unchecked, consolidated control, because He knows the giant always ends up taking.
This isn't anti-government. Government is God's servant for our good (Romans 13). It's a warning about concentration: the moment safety becomes the god we'll trade anything for, the thing we built to save us starts taking from us, one tenth at a time. We were told it would. We asked for the king anyway.
So we pray: Father, empower us to have faith for a culture of virtue instead of a surveillance state of false security. Give us the courage to trust You for the safety no government was ever able to keep.
The news wants you anxious and angry. You just got equipped, not enraged.
→ Get the Faith Check free at FaithCheck.news.
Original reporting by The Center Square.
Faith Check News
Curating daily news stories for Christian readers.
CONNECT OTHERS
© 2025. All rights reserved.